AI comic grading apps compared
Four photo-grading tools and CGC's own Grade PreScreen, side by side. We list what each one costs, what it sends back, and whether it answers the question you actually have: should this book go to CGC?
Published by ComicMintAI, which is one of the tools on this page. Every competitor figure links to its own site.
Robograder, AI Comic Grading and TrueComix (formerly ComicSnap) estimate a comic's grade from photos for roughly $0.50 to $2 a grade, and Robograder also shows a fair-market-value range. ComicMintAI is the one that adds CGC's fees to the picture and tells you to submit or skip before you ship. CGC Grade PreScreen only filters after the book reaches CGC.
The side-by-side table
Prices are the ones each company publishes on its own site or app-store listing. Where a company doesn't say, the cell says so instead of guessing.
| Tool | Runs on | Published price | Free tier | Grade output | Value estimate | CGC fee math + submit verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ComicMintAI | Any browser (phone or desktop). No native app. | Free under $50 · $9 for 5 · $12 for one book · $39 for 10 · $79 for 50 (one-time) | 2 free checks with an email account (grade band + confidence) | Grade band on the 0.5–10.0 scale, confidence level, written notes per area | AI estimate, raw and slabbed | Yes: tier fee, break-even grade, GO / NO-GO / PRESS FIRST |
| Robograder | Web, iOS, Android | 5 for $10 · 20 for $30 · 100 for $100 ($2.00 → $1.00 each) | Not published (1 credit for a return web login) | Single grade on 0.5–9.9, scores for front, back, spine and interior, page quality | Fair-market-value range | No |
| AI Comic Grading | iOS, Android | 5 for $3.99 · 15 for $9.99 · 40 for $19.99 | 3 a day in week one, then 3 a week, then 2 a month | Single grade (0.5–10.0) with label, defect breakdown, certificate number | Not stated | No |
| TrueComix (was ComicSnap) | Web, iOS | Plans $1.99–$9.99 a month, or scan packs $5–$20 | Free plan with a small monthly scan allowance | AI grade (advertises ±0.5) | Market value | No |
| CGC Grade PreScreen | Mail-in add-on to a CGC submission | Tier fee if it passes, $9 per rejected book ($5 in bulk, 25-book minimum) | None | A real CGC grade, but only slabbed if it meets your minimum | None | Partly: a grade floor, applied after you've shipped and paid postage |
Sources: robograder.app and its App Store listing; aicomicgrading.com and its App Store listing; truecomix.com/pricing; CGC services and fees; ComicMintAI's pricing page.
What each tool sends back
Every tool here starts the same way: you photograph the book and get a grade estimate. They split on what comes after.
- Robograder
- AI Comic Grading
- TrueComix
- ComicMintAI
- Robograder (FMV range)
- AI Comic Grading
- TrueComix
- ComicMintAI (raw + slabbed)
- Robograder
- AI Comic Grading
- TrueComix
- ComicMintAI
- Robograder
- AI Comic Grading
- TrueComix
- ComicMintAI
A grade on its own doesn't tell you whether to send the book. A 9.4 is worth slabbing on one title and a waste of $30 on another. What decides it is the gap between the raw price and the slabbed price at that grade, set against the tier fee, handling and postage. That arithmetic is laid out in is it worth grading a comic.
Where each one is the better pick
Best if you want a native app and per-area scores
It has iOS and Android apps, Google and Apple sign-in, separate scores for front, back, spine and interior, and a fair-market-value range. At $1 a grade in the 100-pack, it's cheap for volume. It doesn't do the CGC fee math.
Best if you just want the cheapest grade
At $0.50 a grade in the 40-credit pack, it's the lowest published price here, and the free allowance in the first week is generous. You get one grade number and a defect list, with no value or fee math.
Best if you want a subscription with values
It pairs grading with market value on a monthly plan from $1.99. It's a good fit if you scan steadily and want a value attached to each book.
Best when you've already decided to ship
A real CGC grader looks at the book, and you only pay for a slab if it hits your minimum grade. You still pay postage both ways and $9 for each reject, and you learn the answer after the book has made the trip.
Best when the question is "should I send it?"
It's the only one here that prices CGC's tier fee against the raw and slabbed estimates and returns GO, NO-GO or PRESS FIRST with a break-even grade. The trade-offs are real. It runs in the browser, with no native app. You need an email account. The value figures are AI estimates, not a list of sold comps. And a $12 single verdict costs more than a grade-only app (the 5-pack is $1.80 a book, and books it values under $50 are free).
What CGC itself charges
Every one of these tools is measured against the same bill. These are CGC's published non-member comic tiers; members save 10–20%.
| CGC tier | Fee per book | Max value | Estimated turnaround |
|---|---|---|---|
| Modern Bulk (25-book minimum) | $27 | $400 | 60 working days |
| Modern | $30 | $400 | 60 working days |
| Vintage Bulk / Vintage | $42 / $45 | $400 | 60 working days |
| High Value | $105 | $1,000 | 10 working days |
| Unlimited Value | 4% of FMV, $135 min | No cap | 5 working days |
On top of the tier fee, CGC adds $5 handling per online invoice ($8 on paper), plus shipping and insurance both ways. Our comic grading cost breakdown works through a full invoice.
Which one to use
- You're cataloguing a long box and just want rough grades: a grade-only app is the cheaper tool.
- You want a value next to the grade: Robograder or TrueComix.
- You're deciding whether one specific book, or which books in a pile, are worth CGC's fee: that's the job ComicMintAI is built for. Start with the two free checks on the comic grading app.
- You're already shipping a submission and want insurance against a low grade: add CGC Grade PreScreen.
None of these apps replaces a CGC slab for resale. Each one says so in its own terms, and so do we. See pre-grading before CGC for how to use a photo grade before a submission.
How we checked
On November 6, 2026 we read each company's own website and app-store listing and copied the published prices and output descriptions. We didn't run the same book through every app, so this page compares what each tool says it does, not how accurate it is. No tool on this page, ComicMintAI included, publishes an independent accuracy test. If a figure here is out of date, tell us through the contact page and we'll fix it.
Questions collectors ask
What's the best app to pre-grade comics before sending them to CGC?
It depends on the question. For a cheap grade estimate, AI Comic Grading ($0.50–$0.80 a grade) or Robograder ($1–$2) are the low-cost picks. To find out whether the submission pays after CGC's fees, ComicMintAI is the one that runs that math and returns a submit-or-skip verdict before you ship.
Does CGC have a grading app?
CGC doesn't offer an AI photo-grading app. Its closest service is Grade PreScreen, an add-on to a mail-in submission that only slabs books meeting your minimum grade, at $9 per rejected book. Every AI app on this page is independent of CGC.
How much does AI comic grading cost?
Published prices run from $0.50 a grade (AI Comic Grading's 40-credit pack) to $2 a grade (Robograder's 5-pack). ComicMintAI's free checks give a grade band, and the full verdict is free for a book it values under $50. For books worth more, its paid verdicts cost $9 for five books, $12 for one, $39 for ten or $79 for fifty, because they include the CGC fee analysis.
Are AI comic grades accurate?
They're estimates from photos, and photos hide some defects a grader holding the book would catch. TrueComix advertises ±0.5. None of these tools publishes an independent test against returned CGC grades, so treat any single number as a starting point. ComicMintAI returns a band with a confidence level for that reason.
What does CGC Grade PreScreen cost?
You pay the normal tier fee if the book meets your minimum grade and gets slabbed, or $9 per rejected book. Bulk Grade PreScreen charges $5 per reject but needs at least 25 books. Postage both ways applies either way.
Find out if this book is worth sending
Two free checks give you the grade band and confidence, and a book valued under $50 gets its full verdict free. For books worth more, the verdict adds the CGC tier fee, the break-even grade and a straight GO or NO-GO.